Freedom Action of the Week
Email List Archive

[Date Prev] | [Date Next]



 Free-Market.Net's  F r e e d o m  A c t i o n  o f  t h e  W e e k
 ------------------------------------------------------------------
 Edited by Thomas L. Knapp. To subscribe or unsubscribe to this and
 other lists, click to: http://www.free-market.net/features/lists/

 ----- Featured Action of the Week -----

First Week of June, 2001:
Free Paul Bryan

Sometimes the great people here at Free-Market.Net cover 
for each other. Sometimes, they do so without even meaning to. 
This week's action opportunity is one of those cases. I'm going 
to give my usual pep talk, but then I'm going to turn you over 
to J.D. Tuccille, who will make it easy for you to do what  
needs to be done. In passing, I'd also like to thank 
Free-Market.Net member Paul Miniato, who brought the situation 
at hand to our attention.

It would be a mistake to call democracy a libertarian notion 
as such. One man, one vote does not always render the best 
result if freedom is what we're after. But democracy, at least 
to some extent, is the best system we've been able to come up 
with for making political decisions in an optimal manner: 
instead of entrusting power to an individual or an oligarchy, 
we disperse that power and use the force of our arguments 
to convince a majority of the individuals to whom it is dispersed 
of the correctness of the course we recommend.

Like I said, it isn't perfect. It can and does fail.  And it 
is more likely to fail, and fail catastrophically, if we monkey 
around with the underlying mechanisms that make it work. One 
of those mechanisms is recognizing the right to freedom of speech. 
Dispersal of power via democracy is _guaranteed_ not to work if 
the voters are denied access to information on which to base 
their decisions.

Which brings us to Paul Bryan. He's one of us -- a member 
of Free-Market.Net since 1998 -- and he's also the proprietor 
of a web site that features Canadian election news. He's also 
in trouble with the Canadian government for violating a law 
that imposes censorship on election results until all of the 
polls are closed.

Arguments can be made that posting election results from 
the East can affect the outcome in the West. Those arguments 
are irrelevant. The _point_ of political speech is to affect 
election results ... isn't it?

Mr. Bryan faces a fine of up to $25,000 (Canadian). Not for 
scrawling graffiti on someone else's property, or punching 
someone in the nose. Not even for lying or committing fraud, 
but for conveying _accurate information_ (which he has a right 
to do) to the public (who have a right to read it).

As I stated earlier, Mr. Tuccille has done the legwork on this. 
Instead of posting a rehash of the links here, I'm sending you 
to his civil liberties site at About.Com to read his take on 
the issue. The article includes a summary of the case, links 
to relevant information, and, most importantly, contact 
information for Elections Canada, the enforcement body which 
is bringing these ridiculous charges.

The action should be self-evident: use that information 
to convey your displeasure. You don't have to be from Canada. 
Suppression of free speech is an international problem with 
international implications. Countries like Canada (and 
the United States) are the ones who insist on sending election 
observers to countries with bad human rights records. Canada has 
just joined that category, and it's perfectly proper for someone 
from Tanzania or Russia or Sri Lanka to take the same steps that 
Canada would if the situation were reversed.

Give'em hell.

P.S. We've added a new feature to Action of the Week: an accessible 
archive of past columns. Feel free to browse -- and to act. Better 
late than never!

Free Paul Bryan, by J.D. Tuccille:
http://civilliberty.about.com/library/briefs/bl053001.htm

Action of the Week column archive:
http://www.free-market.net/features/list-archives/activism/maillist.html


 ----- Alternate Actions -----

The Freedom Action of the Week Club: Commit yourself to doing one
action per week. If the action above doesn't appeal to you, consider
one of the alternate actions at:
     http://www.free-market.net/features/action/

If you know about another action or organize one of your own, e-mail
Tom at tlknapp@free-market.net so we can tell the rest of the group
next week.

 -----------------------------------------------------------------
 Please forward and copy freely, and include the following:

 The Freedom Action of the Week is a feature of Free-Market.Net
     http://www.free-market.net/features/action/
 Opinions expressed are purely those of our writers and editors.
 To subscribe or unsubscribe to this and other lists, click to:
     http://www.free-market.net/features/lists/

 To support the Action of the Week and other activities of FMN
 and The Henry Hazlitt Foundation, please make a tax-deductible
 donation now: 
 -----------------------------------------------------------------

_________________________________________________________________________
  Thomas L. Knapp    | "Your genuine action will explain itself, and will
  Managing Editor    |  explain your other genuine actions.  Your con-
  Free- Market.Net   |  formity explains nothing."
                     |                           --Ralph Waldo Emerson
       
_________________________________________________________________________





In December 2004 this page was modified significantly from its original form for archiving purposes.

, founded in 1995, is now a part of ISIL.

directNIC Search
Hosted by directNIC.com